Here’s a thought experiment. You get mud on your arm. Do you wipe it off with a dry paper towel, or rinse it with water? Nobody picks the paper towel, yet that’s the plan most Americans bring to the most important cleanup of the day. Much of the world rinses instead: bidets are commonplace across Asia, Europe, South America, and northern Africa, and they’re gaining popularity in the U.S.[1] In Japan, 80.2% of households had an electric bidet toilet by March 2020.[8] So which side of the bowl is right? We went through the research on hygiene, health, cost, and the planet.

Which gets you cleaner?

Water, and it isn’t especially close. As a Cleveland Clinic gastroenterologist puts it, water tops a few squares of dry paper at removing the last traces of poop, and wiping carries a real risk of getting it on your hands and under your nails.[1] A Cleveland Clinic colorectal surgeon goes further: “A bidet is the gold standard.”[2]

There’s data behind the hand part. In a Japanese study, 32 nursing students wore double gloves on their wiping hand and wiped with four layers of toilet paper, once after using a bidet and once without. Without a rinse, the outer glove picked up an average of about 39,500 colony-forming units of microbes. With a rinse first, it was about 4,100, roughly a tenth as many.[3] Either way, wash your hands with soap afterward; Cleveland Clinic recommends a good 30-second scrub even when you use a bidet.[1]

Is a bidet gentler on your skin?

Usually, yes. Wiping can cause chafing and tiny cuts, and a bidet sidesteps most of that. It can also feel more comfortable if you have hemorrhoids or a fissure.[1] Too much wiping is a recognized cause of tiny tears, burning, and the persistent itch doctors call pruritus ani.[2] Colon and rectal surgeons advise people with an itchy bottom not to scrub the area with anything, toilet paper included, and to rinse with water and pat dry instead.[14]

Wet wipes aren’t the upgrade they look like. Many contain alcohol or fragrance that can irritate the skin, and Cleveland Clinic’s surgeon says you’re better off with plain toilet paper, or better yet, a bidet.[2]

Bidets and hemorrhoids: what the studies show

Here’s where it gets interesting. Some surveys found bidet users had more hemorrhoids, which sounds bad until you ask which came first. A Keio University team followed 7,637 people in Japan for a year. Bidet users were more likely to already have hemorrhoids at the start, but they were no more likely to develop new ones during the year. The researchers concluded the link was reverse causation: people with sore bottoms switch to water, not the other way round.[5]

A 2022 systematic review of the studies on bidets and benign anal conditions reached the same place. Two prospective studies and a survey found habitual bidet use didn’t change the odds of developing hemorrhoids or hemorrhoid symptoms, and one randomized trial found a bidet worked as well as a sitz bath for pain after hemorrhoid surgery. The reviewers were clear that the evidence is limited and doesn’t yet support bidets as a treatment.[4]

There’s a plausible soothing effect, too. In 20 healthy volunteers, a warm (38°C), low-to-medium pressure stream lowered resting pressure in the anal canal, much like a warm sitz bath does, while cooler water and stronger jets didn’t.[6] So for comfort during a flare, a gentle warm rinse is a reasonable choice; for actually treating hemorrhoids, the playbook in our hemorrhoids guide (fiber, less straining, shorter toilet sessions) still does the heavy lifting.

The catch: you can overdo it

The best evidence on bidet downsides comes from Japan, where bidet toilets are everywhere and some people use them enthusiastically. The pattern is consistent: the trouble comes from how people wash, not from washing.

Itching from overwashing

In a survey of 4,963 people in Japan, 55% used a bidet, and at least 30% of users also washed before pooping, partly to help things along. Anal itching was linked to washing before a bowel movement, using warmer water after one, and leakage, along with being male or younger.[7] In that survey, about 14% of respondents reported anal itching. The likely mechanism: overwashing strips the skin’s natural oils and dries it out.[8] The systematic review likewise found studies suggesting that habitual bidet use may raise the odds of pruritus ani.[4]

This lines up with what colorectal surgeons see generally. Excessive cleaning can remove the skin’s natural barriers and make itching worse, and scented soaps and lotions can irritate.[14] Hot water can irritate the area as well.[15] The good news: in one report, all 94 patients with anal itching who were told to stop excessive washing (and skip steroid creams) recovered.[8]

Leakage in heavy users

If water gets in rather than just rinsing the outside, it may act like a mini enema. In 49 people with anal incontinence who habitually used a bidet, pausing it for a median of four weeks cut the share with fecal leakage from 88% to 59%, and their severity scores dropped too.[9] It’s a small retrospective study, but the advice that follows from it is easy: if you have any leakage, stop using the bidet and see whether it improves.[8]

Strong jets can injure

A case series described ten anterior anal fissures linked to bidet sessions of one to five minutes, likely from strong water pressure held too long.[8] In another case, a woman who washed five or more times a day, for a minute or more each time, with a strong, thin jet developed a small ulcer in the anorectum; it healed completely within five weeks of stopping.[10] Those are extremes, but they make the point: a bidet is a rinse, not a pressure washer.

Vaginal health and direction of spray

A Japanese gynecology study of 268 women with increased discharge found that habitual bidet users were far more likely to be missing their normal protective Lactobacillus bacteria (42.9% vs. 8.8%), and 46 of the 50 women with fecal bacteria were bidet users.[11] That study couldn’t rule out reverse causation, though.[5] The larger one-year follow-up study found a small rise in symptoms of bacterial vaginitis among habitual users (1.2% vs. 0.8% developed it), though the authors said the numbers were too small to be conclusive.[5] The practical takeaway matches Cleveland Clinic’s advice: the water should flow front to back, at a pressure and angle that doesn’t force water into the vagina. A bidet is meant to clean the outside of your body, not the inside.[1]

Are bidets themselves clean?

At home, generally yes. A long-term study of warm-water bidet seats on a Japanese university campus found very low bacterial counts in the spray water and concluded that hygienic safety is maintained overall, although biofilm can build up inside the unit over time.[13] Hospitals are a different story. When researchers swabbed all 292 electric bidet toilets at a university hospital, 86.9% of the warm-water nozzles carried bacteria, including some antibiotic-resistant strains.[12] That’s why specialists advise people with weakened immune systems to be cautious with shared bidets in hospitals.[8] For your own bathroom, the rules are simple: clean it as the manual says and never let the nozzle tip touch your body.[1]

The environmental math

Toilet paper has a surprisingly big footprint. Americans make up just over 4% of the world’s population but account for over 20% of global tissue consumption, and much of the pulp comes from Canada’s boreal forest, where industrial logging claims more than a million acres a year, partly to meet U.S. demand for tissue.[16] Tissue made from 100% virgin fiber generates three times as much carbon as tissue made from other types of pulp.[16]

Bidets help by cutting how much paper you use. NRDC’s 2026 report notes they can significantly reduce toilet paper use and the forest and climate impacts that come with it. They aren’t impact-free: water, electricity for heated seats and dryers, and how you use them all matter, and nobody has published a complete cradle-to-grave comparison yet. Simple non-electric attachments are likely the most environmentally favorable type.[17] And for the paper you still use to pat dry, recycled-content brands are an easy win: in NRDC’s analysis of 63 brands, recycled and forest-fiber toilet paper had similar median prices (34 vs. 31 cents per 100 sheets), and the cheapest brand of all was recycled.[17]

What about cost?

The average household spends hundreds of dollars a year on toilet paper, so a bidet can pay for itself over time even after the upfront cost. Bonus: less paper means fewer clogs and fewer dates with the plunger.[1] Expect to keep a roll around for patting dry, so think of it as using far less paper rather than none.[2]

Types of bidets, from simplest to fanciest

Bidets come in a few forms: some attach to the toilet you already have, either mounted at the bowl or on a detachable hose, and others are standalone fixtures that look like a low sink.[1] Here’s how the main options compare.

  • Non-electric attachments. A spray nozzle added to the toilet you already have. They skip heated water, seat warming, and air drying, which likely makes them the lowest-impact type.[17]
  • Handheld sprayers. A wand on a hose that you aim yourself, handy if you want precise control of angle and pressure.[1]
  • Electric bidet seats. Warm water with adjustable force, stream width, and temperature[8], often with seat warming and air drying, which add energy use.[17] Some heat water in a tank and others heat it on demand.[13] In tank types, chlorine in the water fades as it’s heated, which lets bacteria multiply, so regular cleaning matters.[8]
  • Standalone bidets. The classic separate fixture that looks like a low sink.[1]

A bidet also makes cleanup easier for anyone with arthritis, limited mobility, or trouble reaching to wipe.[1]

How to use a bidet (the right way)

  1. Finish your business first. Washing before a bowel movement is one of the habits linked to anal itching.[7]
  2. Start gentle. Choose low pressure and, if you have the option, a wide stream. One specialist limits patients to under five seconds of weak, wide spray.[8]
  3. Go lukewarm, not hot. Comfortably warm water relaxes the area[6], but hotter water is linked to itching.[7, 15]
  4. Aim front to back and keep the water on the outside of your body.[1]
  5. Pat dry. A few squares of toilet paper or a towel, patted, not rubbed.[2, 14]
  6. Wash your hands anyway, and clean the bidet as the manual directs.[1]

Sticking with paper? Wipe gently, don’t scrub, and choose plain, dye-free, unscented toilet paper if your skin is sensitive.[2, 15]

Who should be careful

  • Anyone with anal itching: cut back on washing and keep it short and gentle.[8]
  • Anyone with leakage or incontinence: stop using the bidet for a few weeks and see if it improves, then talk with a doctor.[8, 9]
  • People with a vagina: spray front to back at low pressure, and mention bidet use to your doctor if you’re dealing with recurring discharge or vaginal infections.[1, 11]
  • People with weakened immune systems using shared bidets in hospitals or similar settings.[8, 12]

Itching that doesn’t improve with gentler care, gets worse, or looks infected is worth a call to your healthcare provider.[15] The same goes for bleeding from your bottom, which is often from hemorrhoids but still deserves a doctor’s look.

The verdict

For cleaning, a bidet wins: cleaner hands, gentler skin, less paper, and a smaller footprint. Use it like a rinse, not a pressure washer, and you get the benefits without the itch. Want the full upgrade? Pair it with a toilet stool, and see why bathrooms are worth celebrating on World Toilet Day. And when you’re out and about, DookieMaps finds you the nearest restroom fast.