Look down next time you’re in a public restroom and you’ll almost always see it: a horseshoe-shaped seat with a gap at the front. Go home and the seat is a closed O. Same toilet, same job, two different shapes. The internet has plenty of theories about why, from saving plastic to fitting more body types.[1, 4, 5] The real answer is more specific, a little more personal, and written into the plumbing code.

The short answer: the plumbing code requires it

Two model plumbing codes are used across the U.S., and both call for open-front seats in public restrooms.

  • The Uniform Plumbing Code (UPC), published by the International Association of Plumbing and Mechanical Officials (IAPMO), says seats “for public use shall be of the elongated type and either of the open front type or have an automatic seat cover dispenser.”[7]
  • The International Plumbing Code (IPC) says seats in “public or employee toilet facilities shall be of the hinged open-front type,” and that the bowls there must be elongated.[8] The same rule sat in section 420.3 of earlier editions.[9] That “employee” part means the restroom at your office counts too, even if the public never sees it.

A model code isn’t a law on its own. It becomes one when a city, county, or state adopts it, often with local tweaks, and most public authorities in the U.S. have. The UPC alone applied, in some form, to more than half the U.S. population as of 2013.[1, 2, 3]

Why the gap? The hygiene reason, straight from the code writers

When Slate asked IAPMO in 2013, Lynne Simnick, then its senior director of code development, explained that the open front was originally designed for women: it lets them “wipe the perineal area after using the water closet” without touching a seat that might not be clean.[1] Translation: there’s room for your hand, and the toilet paper in it, without brushing the front of the seat.

Everyone else benefits too. Simnick noted that the design “eliminates an area that could be contaminated with urine” and “eliminates the user’s genital contact with the seat.”[1] The American Society of Plumbing Engineers gives the same explanation: the opening keeps the seat from getting contaminated, especially during urination, and keeps genitals off it.[6] And in a 2024 statement to Nexstar, IAPMO’s Hugo Aguilar summed it up: “Open front seats and elongated toilet bowls for public restrooms minimize the risk of the user coming in contact with possible contamination from a previous user.”[5]

That also explains the elongated-bowl rule riding alongside it. An elongated bowl reaches about 2 inches farther forward than a round one, which gives a bigger target and helps keep things cleaner in a restroom used by lots of people.[6]

One modern footnote: the NHS advises wiping front to back, because wiping back to front can carry bacteria from poop into the urinary tract and raise the risk of a UTI, especially for women, who have a shorter urethra.[12] Writers at Mental Floss and IFLScience have pointed out the irony.[2, 4] Happily, the gap gives you room to wipe in whichever direction you need.

Since when? A rule from the 1950s

According to IAPMO technical services manager Dan Cole, the open-front requirement first appeared in the American Standard National Plumbing Code in 1955 and was added to the Uniform Plumbing Code in 1973.[2] The 1955 wording was blunt: “All seats of water closets provided for public use shall be of the open-front type.”[3]

So why is my seat at home a closed O?

Because the rule only applies to public (and, under the IPC, employee) restrooms.[7, 8] Your bathroom at home isn’t either, so you get whatever seat you buy, and most people buy a closed one.[1]

Hotel rooms work the same way. Indiana’s building commissioner ruled that toilets in individual hotel and motel guest bathrooms don’t need open-front seats. The code’s definition of “public” covers general toilet rooms in places like schools, airports, stores, restaurants, stadiums, offices, and the shared restrooms in hotels, where multiple fixtures are open to anyone. A private guest bathroom doesn’t fit.[9]

Why do some public restrooms still have closed seats?

A few legit reasons:

  • A seat-cover dispenser. Under the UPC, a public toilet can keep a closed seat if it has an automatic seat-cover dispenser, the kind that slides a fresh plastic sleeve over the seat.[1, 7]
  • Different local rules. Not every state follows the same plumbing regulations, so the details vary by where you are.[5]
  • A swapped seat. You don’t need a permit to change a toilet seat, as the UPC technical committee pointed out while reviewing proposals for the 2024 edition, so a replacement seat doesn’t get an inspector’s second look.[13]

The other perks of an open-front seat

  • Less material. A U uses less plastic than an O, so it’s cheaper to make.[2]
  • Harder to steal. Yes, really. A U.K. restroom operator told Mental Floss that seat theft is a major problem there, so many British public toilets now skip seats altogether.[2]
  • No lid to touch. A classic commercial seat like Bemis’s 1955CT is sold “open front less cover,” meaning no lid at all, in heavy-duty plastic made to resist chips, wear, and stains.[11]
  • They stay put. The 2010 ADA Standards say accessible toilet seats can’t be spring-loaded to pop back up, and the seat must sit 17 to 19 inches off the floor.[10] Commercial seats like the 1955CT use check hinges that stop the seat from tipping more than 11° past vertical.[11]

How to use an open-front seat like a pro

  • Sit, don’t hover. The seat is designed so you can sit and still keep the parts that matter off it. Hovering tends to spray the seat for the next person.[5]
  • Use the gap. It’s there for wiping room, so you can clean up without scraping your hand along the seat.[1]
  • Wipe front to back. It’s the NHS’s top tip for preventing UTIs.[12]
  • Finish at the sink. Soap, water, and a proper scrub.

Worried about what’s actually living on that seat? We break it down in can you get sick from a toilet seat, and how to clean a toilet seat covers the one at home. For more restroom design mysteries, read why bathroom stalls have gaps, and for the backstory of the whole contraption, see who really invented the flush toilet. Team water? Check out bidet vs. toilet paper.

The bottom line

Public toilet seats are U-shaped because the plumbing code requires it, and the code requires it for hygiene: the gap gives you room to wipe without touching the seat, removes the spot most likely to catch urine, and keeps sensitive skin off a surface plenty of strangers have used. It’s been the rule since 1955, and it’s why the seat at home looks different. Next time you’re out and need a restroom fast, DookieMaps finds the nearest one in a tap.